Expansion of Right to Work checks: What Construction businesses need to know

17
commercial solar panel install
Image: © sturti | iStock

Construction firms should review their labour supply chains following the government’s major Right to Work shake-up, writes Mandeep Khroud, head of immigration at law firm Irwin Mitchell

On 1 October, the government introduced one of the biggest changes to illegal working compliance since Right to Work checks were first introduced, representing a fundamental shift in how Right to Work compliance is assessed.

For construction businesses, many of which rely heavily on subcontractors, labour supply chains and flexible workforce arrangements, the reforms have significant implications, drastically expanding immigration compliance beyond traditional employees, apprentices and specific worker contracts.

As a result, it is vital that those operating in the construction sector understand precisely how labour enters their business, where legal responsibility sits and whether existing compliance processes remain fit for purpose.

While Right to Work compliance has historically been viewed as an HR and recruitment issue within traditional employer-employee relationships, responsibility for preventing illegal working now extends much further, potentially affecting procurement teams, contractor management processes, labour supply arrangements and wider workforce supply chains.

Which working arrangements are now covered?

The Right to Work scheme now applies to:

  • Individuals engaged under worker contracts.
  • Individual subcontractors.
  • Certain outsourced labour arrangements.
  • Arrangements containing substitution rights, where one individual may perform work on behalf of another.
  • Online matching and platform-based services.

The Home Office guidance makes clear that the definition of “employer” extends beyond traditional employment relationships and can include businesses engaging individual subcontractors, worker-contract arrangements and other labour supply models.

Importantly, labels such as “self-employed” or “contractor” will not be determinative. The Home Office has made clear that the assessment will focus on the reality of the arrangement and how work is supplied and performed in practice.

For example, a contractor engaging a labour-only subcontractor may need to consider whether additional Right to Work compliance obligations arise within that arrangement, depending on how the relationship operates in practice.

Which arrangements remain outside scope?

Despite the broader application, not every commercial arrangement will fall within scope, and the guidance confirms that the extended liability provisions generally do not apply where a business is simply purchasing services for its own internal operations.

Likewise, genuine business-to-business arrangements involving independent contractors operating through their own companies will generally remain outside the framework.

This distinction will be critical, and many organisations may require specialist advice to determine whether particular working arrangements fall within scope.

What steps must construction firms now ensure have been taken?

Construction businesses that fall within the extended liability provisions will need to establish a statutory excuse against that liability. To benefit from that protection, organisations must demonstrate compliance before work begins.

The requirements are as follows:

1. Contractual controls: Businesses must have written contractual provisions requiring Right to Work compliance throughout the relevant contractual chain.

2. Substitution controls: Where contractual arrangements permit one individual to substitute another to perform the work, businesses must ensure there are appropriate processes in place to verify the identity and Right to Work status of any substitute before work commences.

Organisations should not assume that a check carried out on the original worker will cover subsequent substitutes.

3. Identity verification: Businesses must have systems ensuring that the individual carrying out the work is the individual whose Right to Work has been verified.

What are the consequences of non-compliance?

The risks remain significant. Businesses that fail to establish a statutory excuse may face:

  • Civil penalties of up to £60,000 per illegal worker.
  • Criminal liability in serious cases.
  • A suspension or revocation of the organisation’s sponsorship licence.
  • Public naming as a non-compliant employer.

The Home Office has also made clear that intelligence sharing with HMRC and other enforcement bodies will continue to underpin enforcement activity to identify those businesses who are non-compliant.

Construction compliance checklist

Construction businesses should ask themselves:

  • Do we know every route through which labour is supplied to our projects?
  • Have we reviewed all subcontractor and labour-only arrangements?
  • Have we identified which relationships fall inside and outside the extended Right to Work regime?
  • Do our contracts contain appropriate Right to Work obligations?
  • Can we verify the identity of workers and substitutes before they begin work?
  • Are managers and site supervisors aware of the new
    requirements?
  • Have we documented our processes sufficiently to establish a statutory excuse if challenged?
  • Have procurement, commercial and site management teams been trained on the new requirements?

The recent reforms mark a significant shift in the UK’s approach to illegal working enforcement. For construction businesses operating complex labour supply chains, understanding who is carrying out Right to Work checks, when those checks must take place and how compliance is documented will be essential.

Contributors

Editor's Picks

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here